We show that the secret sharing scheme [Cryptogr. Commun. 16(1): 3-20 (2024)] cannot be put into practice. (1) It confused the elements in a residue class ring modulo a prime with the points in an elliptic curve group over the finite field . (2) It confused the underlying elliptic curve with the Lagrange interpolating curve, and falsely requires the interpolating polynomial to map a point on the elliptic curve to another point on the same elliptic curve. (3) It misuses the bit-wise XOR operator for the operands with unequal bit-length, which results in the exposure of any participant's share, and the loss of confidentiality.